Sherman
Alexie’s idea throughout This is What it
Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona is that stories are meant to be told for the
reconnection of past and future generations.
Some may reject it and some may not, but it does not matter as long as the
stories continue to get told (72).
The
beginning of This is What it Means to Say
Phoenix, Arizona starts out with a disconnection, the death of Victor’s
father. The disconnection of his community is seen by his move to Phoenix,
Arizona and also because he has not spoken to his son in a few years, and when
they did talk it was on the phone (59). Victor’s father can also represent the
past, while Victor represents the future.
Another
representation of disconnection in this story is the tribal counsel. In the story Victor goes to the tribal
counsel in order to get money to go retrieve his father’s ashes. The tribal counsel’s response was
“Now,
Victor, we do have some money available for the proper return of tribal
members’ bodies. But I don’t think we
have enough to bring your father all the way back from Phoenix (60)”.
The tribal
counsel is the one place one would think that would be able and willing to
preserve the past, but they are not. Due
to the lack of money within the counsel they cannot help Victor reconnect his
past.
The one person that can help Victor with
this connection is Thomas Builds-the-Fire.
Victor and Thomas had been childhood friends, and Thomas was willing to
help Victor as long as Victor took him along to Phoenix. After some thought Victor agreed. Thomas is known for his story telling, but he
was also an outsider because of it. In a
way Thomas’ gift was also a curse, because of the rejection it caused him.
“Nobody
talked to Thomas anymore because he told the same damn stories over and over
again. (62)”
Throughout the trip Thomas is
telling Victor stories, and they both are reminiscing. The most important story of them all would be
the last one that Thomas tells. It is a
story about how Thomas first met Victor’s father. Thomas had a vision that told him to go to
Spokane, stand by the Falls, and wait for a sign. The vision turned out to be Victor’s father,
and Thomas’ dreams was telling him to, “Take care of each other (69).” After hearing this Victor was quiet. This was finally the reconnection he had been
waiting for. Thomas had given Victor an
even greater gift than money. He gave
him memories. “ He searched his mind for memories of his father, found the good
ones, found the a few bad ones, added it all up, and smiled. (69)”
Even though Thomas had given Victor
the gift of memories through his stories, Victor still chose to reject
him. “ Victor knew that he couldn’t
really be friends with Thomas, even after all that happened (74)”. In the end Thomas understood. He was not mad about Victor’s rejection,
because some may reject it and some may not, but it does not matter as long as
the stories continue to get told (72).
Whitney, wow! I honestly did not think that the message was that as long as the story is told, then who cares if people care to listen or not, but after reading your blog I would have to say I am convinced. You had good specific examples of the stories that Thomas shared with Victor and you even brought it back to the fact that Victor decides to reject those stories, much like his people on the reservation have been doing.
ReplyDelete